Acres

Rent vs. buy

Compares what you'd be worth after renting and investing the difference with what you'd be worth after buying.

After 10 years

Buying wins by $70,505

Buying pulls ahead in year 5.

Renting

$
%
Capped at 5% through 2027
$
Monthly

Buying

$
%
%
$
Tax, legal, inspection
$
$
%
Of the home's value
$
Monthly
%
Commission, HST, legal
Amortization

Assumptions

%
Per year
%
On what the renter invests
%
Tax, insurance, fees
Compare over

What you'd be worth

If you buyHome value after selling costs, minus the mortgage, plus anything invested
$271,581
If you rentYour down payment and closing costs invested, plus monthly savings
$201,077

First month

OwningMortgage $2,311 + tax, insurance, upkeep
$3,144
RentingRent + tenant insurance
$2,225
Cash to buyDown payment + closing costs
$55,000
The answer swings most on home price growth, the investment return and how long you stay. Try a few versions before deciding.
How it works
  • The buyer pays the down payment, closing costs, mortgage, property tax, insurance, condo fees and upkeep. The renter pays rent and tenant insurance.
  • The renter invests the cash the buyer spent up front. Each month, whoever has the lower costs invests the difference at your investment return.
  • At the end, the buyer sells: their net worth is the home's value minus selling costs and the mortgage left, plus anything they invested.
  • Rent, property tax, insurance and condo fees rise once a year at the rates you set. Growth rates are your assumptions, not forecasts.

Sources

CMHC: Mortgage loan insurance premiumsGovernment of Nova Scotia: Residential Tenancies Program legislative changes

Estimate only, not financial advice. All growth rates are your assumptions, not forecasts. Ignores taxes on investment gains (a principal residence is tax-free when sold; investments may not be).

Should you rent or buy?

This calculator compares your net worth over the years if you buy a home versus if you keep renting and invest the money you'd have spent on a down payment and closing costs. It counts rent increases, mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, upkeep, how much the home gains in value and the cost to sell it at the end.

  • Buying usually comes out ahead the longer you stay, because closing and selling costs get spread over more years.
  • Renting can win when homes gain value slowly, rates are high, or your investments earn more than the home gains.
  • Small changes in the growth and return rates change the answer a lot, so try a few.

Results are estimates to help you plan, not financial or legal advice. See all calculators